UK Parliament Committee asks whether budget support provides cover for Kagame's Rwanda


KPFA Evening News, 11.10..2012

On November 8th, UK Parliament's International Development Committee held the first of two hearings to reconsider the resumption of budget support to the Government of Rwanda, despite the most recent UN Experts and Human Rights Watch reports that Rwanda is behind the M23 militia's war and atrocities in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.


KPFA Evening News Anchor Sharon Sobotta: On Thursday the United Kingdom Parliament's House of Commons International Development Select Committee held the first of two hearings Former UK International Development Secretary Andrew Mitchell defended the decision to unfreeze budget support to Rwanda before the UK Parliament International Development Select Committee. Screenshot: Courtesy UK Parliament TV. to reconsider budget support to Rwanda, a longtime ally and military partner of both the United States and the United Kingdom. The Committee scheduled the hearings in response to UN investigators' reports that Rwanda is arming, sending soldiers, and even commanding the M23 militia fighting in eastern Congo. KPFA's Ann Garrison has the story.

KPFA/Ann Garrison: The most recent UN investigation, which was leaked to Reuters in mid-October, reported that Rwandan Defense Minister James Kabarebe is commanding the M23 miltia in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo, and that is being armed by Rwanda and Uganda, both of which sent troops to aid the M23 in a lethal attack on U.N. peacekeepers. 

A September Human Rights Watch report on M23's war crimes in Congo included rape, forced recruitment, and summary executions, and the execution of child soldiers who tried to escape. In one of HRW's most horrific atrocity accounts, it said that M23 soldiers broke down a woman's door, beat her 15-year-old son to death, abducted her husband, then gang-raped her, poured fuel between her legs, and set the fuel on fire before leaving.

Other European countries have frozen aid to Rwanda, so the UK Parliament's International Development Committee Chair asked former International Development Secretary Andrew Mitchell to explain why the UK is now standing alone in its decision.

Committee Chair: The question arises, however, as to what extent, if you like, that support gives cover to practices which are much more disreputable, whether it's interfering with a neighboring state, or indeed suppression of the rights of its own citizens, and that's really what this concern is all about.  So you've explained why it was withheld, you've explained the process by which you partially reinstated it . . . but Britain at the moment stands alone on that decision.

KPFA: Mitchell responded, for one, that Rwandan government elites would not be at all affected by the UK's decision to withdraw budget support, but that a Rwandan girls' school might, as a result, be closed. He did not address the issue first raised in earlier UN reports and echoed by the committee chair, which was whether the UK and other donors, by supporting basic services like education and health in Rwanda, were not freeing the Rwandan government to devote other resources to its war in Congo.  
In the street outside the Katinde Nazareen Church in Goma, Congolese women displaying a Congolese national flag demonstrate for peace following an ecumenical service for peace in the east of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Civil society and church leaders called people together on Aug. 1 during a public holiday celebrating parents to pray for peace, saying their faith is stronger than war. North Kivu Province has been wracked by conflict in recent months as M23 rebels pitch themselves against the Congolese army. “We will pray until this thing is over,” said one member of the congregation. – Photo: Phil Moore, Getty Images
Mitchell also said that the UK was not, as the committee chair said, standing alone, because some European nations had frozen budget support to Rwanda, but neither the European Parliament nor the United States had:  

Andrew Mitchell: This suggestion that Britain's gone out on a limb here just isn't true. Let me just give you some of the details. The European Union made no change at all to their programs. They released budget support as planned in September. . .  The American government, the press have pointed out that the American government cut $200,000 of their military aid, which is correct, but what was not reported was that the development program, which is 160 million dollars a year . . . this is a huge development program . . . has not been affected.

KPFA: The UK Parliament's International Development Committee will hold its second hearing on budget support to Rwanda on November 13th.  

For Pacifica, KPFA, and AfrobeatRadio, I'm Ann Garrison.

The second International Development hearing, on 11.13.2012, can be viewed in real time or as an archive at
The  first hearing, on 11.08.2012, is can be viewed as an archive at


Follow Ann Garrison on: